Skip to content


Appellate Practice



Anderson Agostino & Keller, P.C. is well known for its Indiana appellate practice. We have represented clients in the United States Supreme Court, Indiana Supreme Court and intermediate Indiana appellate courts, as well as in the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals. Our clients, who operate in many different industries, include regional organizations and partnerships, governmental bodies, and individuals.

We have brought together a highly skilled group of attorneys whose collective insights bring power and depth to each appeal. After post-trial motions are decided and a notice of appeal is filed, we closely review and synthesize the trial record and consider how a particular appellate court may treat the issues. Our appellate experience enables us to strategically position the legal issues on appeal, craft the best argument possible, and present each client’s case with force and precision. Anderson Agostino & Keller, P.C. attorneys have presented persuasive and successful oral arguments in Indiana appellate courts throughout the state, as well as in federal appeals courts. Our appellate matters relate to a host of subjects and industries, including insurance coverage matters, complex business and contractual disputes, professional liability issues, and regulatory and governmental concerns.

Because of our broad-based reputation for ingenuity and excellence, we often receive requests to work in tandem with trial teams from other law firms on their Indiana appeals, to consult on appellate briefs, or to assist in preparation for oral argument. We also handle and consult on procedures that originate at the appellate level, including mandamus petitions and writs of certiorari. For critically important cases, Anderson Agostino & Keller, P.C. will consider filing or contributing to amicus curiae briefs.

 Experienced Appellate Attorneys

Michael J. Anderson


Peter J. Agostino


Bernard E. Edwards


Tracey S. Schafer